Case studies

Construction defects.
Personal injury questions.

Published case discussions and practical issue briefs on slip-and-fall incidents, fire pit burns, cracked and heaving pools, hydrostatic uplift, and paver or hardscape failures.

Read the condition in context

Published discussions below summarize Scott’s attributed articles. Issue briefs explain the questions a construction investigation may address; they are not accounts of particular retained cases. Each assignment turns on its own evidence and scope.

Issue brief

Personal injury: slip & fall incidents

A slip-and-fall claim may involve a wet pool deck, uneven pavers, an unexpected step, or a difficult transition between surfaces. Construction analysis starts by documenting the reported incident location and the conditions that existed at the relevant time.

Scott’s published discussion of steps and landings highlights inconsistent step geometry, poor visibility, and lighting as issues that deserve attention. For an injury assignment, photographs, measurements, surface materials, drainage, maintenance records, and the incident account help define what needs further examination.

What the analysis needs to explain

The construction review explains the physical environment and its possible role in the reported event. It does not substitute for medical opinions or assume that a defect caused an injury.

Making Safe Steps and Landings
Published experience + issue brief

Fire pit burn incidents

In his published fire-pit safety article, Scott describes investigating incidents in which patrons’ clothing or hair caught fire. The article does not identify the parties or disclose case-specific findings or outcomes.

A fire pit burn investigation considers the feature’s layout and construction alongside flame exposure, weather, nearby seating or walking routes, operating practices, and available incident evidence. The burner, enclosure, gas components, and manufacturer’s installation information help establish the construction context.

What the analysis needs to explain

Fire features receive the same evidence-focused review as pools, pavers, and hardscape. The reported incident must be evaluated against the specific installation and conditions.

Scott Cohen: Fire Pit Safety Tips
Published case discussion

Cracked swimming pools

In “Whose Fault is It Anyway?” Scott describes a pool with extensive shell cracking, leakage, damaged glass tile, and movement toward a downslope retaining wall. The construction involved several participants and interacting site conditions.

The article follows the relationship between site conditions, plans, construction details, and the damaged pool. Leakage and expansive clay compounded the problem. A cracked shell is a starting observation; the investigation must examine how the supporting ground and adjoining construction behaved.

What the analysis needs to explain

Pool defect analysis connects the damage to the construction record before assigning a cause or defining repairs. The source discussion illustrates why responsibility may involve more than one trade.

Whose Fault is It Anyway?
Published case discussion

Heaving pools & moving decks

In “Expansive Errors,” the initial allegation was that a pool had sunk. Scott’s inspection instead identified heaved decking and a sequence of failures involving expansive soil, the skimmer, leakage, and movement of the pool shell.

The deck’s movement damaged a skimmer connected to both deck and shell. Escaping water then worsened saturation around the shallow end; the published account describes the pool lifting and cracking. It illustrates the need to separate deck heave, shell movement, and groundwater effects.

What the analysis needs to explain

“The pool moved” does not identify which element moved first. The chronology and construction interfaces can explain the progression of damage.

Expansive Errors
Mechanism + published case discussion

Hydrostatic pressure lifting pools

Water pressure outside a pool shell can create upward force. When the available resistance is insufficient—particularly in an emptied pool—the vessel can lift or “pop.” Hydrostatic uplift is distinct from soil expansion, although moisture conditions can contribute to both.

Scott’s “Singing the Relief-Valve Blues” explains the purpose of hydrostatic relief and describes a missing valve that allowed major leakage and saturated the surrounding ground. In that particular case, the decks heaved; the pool itself did not pop. The distinction matters when explaining the evidence.

What the analysis needs to explain

Investigate the actual pressure and moisture conditions rather than treating every raised deck or displaced shell as a pool pop-up.

Singing the Relief-Valve Blues
Issue brief

Paver settlement & hardscape defects

Uneven pavers, settled walkways, lifted slabs, and displaced coping can create both construction disputes and questions about a reported trip or fall. The review considers the entire assembly, including what is below the visible surface.

Field documentation may include changes in elevation, joint patterns, edge conditions, drainage paths, and transitions to pools or buildings. Plans and installation records help identify the intended base preparation, materials, and relationship to adjacent work. Further testing or specialist input is considered where needed.

What the analysis needs to explain

The repair question and the injury question may require different evidence. Both start with a documented understanding of the physical condition.

Scott Cohen’s published areas of expertise
Start with the construction question

Put the field experience to work.

Discuss the disputed work, the assignment, and your deadlines.

Discuss Your Case